New Balance generally accepts eligible items in new condition within 45 days. Its online policy counts from shipment and store purchases from purchase, though one store-return FAQ uses purchase date for online orders. Returns at New Balance stores are free; mailed online returns are free for members and cost nonmembers $5 per return. Store purchases cannot be mailed.
How to start a return
In a store
- Bring the item in new condition, complete packaging and your receipt or online order proof to a New Balance or New Balance Factory store within the applicable 45-day window.
- Ask the associate to locate the transaction and process the return to the original payment method.
Online or by mail
- For a NewBalance.com purchase, open the official return flow and select the eligible item.
- Use the issued label for the correct box, retain tracking, and allow warehouse processing after delivery.
What is the New Balance return window?
New Balance's standard U.S. return window is 45 days for an eligible item in new condition. For an online purchase, the posted headline counts from shipment; for a retail purchase, it counts from the purchase date. There is a wrinkle in the retailer's own FAQ: one answer about bringing a web order into a store says 45 days from purchase. If an order spent several days between checkout and shipping, those dates do not match. To avoid a counter dispute, plan an in-store return by the earlier purchase date, or ask New Balance customer service to confirm the order's deadline. Keep the shipment notice and receipt so the timing can be checked. A product marked final sale or covered by a separate offer may not follow the ordinary rule. The standard window is a deadline for eligibility, not a promise that a worn product will be accepted.
How do you return a New Balance purchase in a store?
Bring the shoes, apparel or accessory, proof of purchase and original payment details to a New Balance or New Balance Factory store. New Balance says items bought online, at an official store or at an event may be returned at its stores when eligible. The store route is free and the refund is processed immediately there, although a bank may take longer to show the credit. For a web order, use the order confirmation, packing list or purchase email so the associate can find the transaction. Bring the complete product and its packaging rather than only a shoebox or a photo of the item. A Factory Store is an accepted return location under the general policy, but a Factory Store promotion may have its own item-level terms. Ask the associate about the actual purchase if it was clearance or a limited offer. A third-party sporting goods store is not a New Balance store for this purpose.
Can you take an eligible New Balance return to a Factory Store?
A New Balance Factory Store is an accepted location under the general policy. A particular Factory Store promotion can still have its own item-level terms. Bring the complete merchandise and purchase proof, and ask about that transaction’s eligibility.
How do you return a NewBalance.com order by mail?
Go to New Balance's official return page and use the online return flow for the order. Select the products, follow the label instructions and send the package to the stated carrier. Save the tracking number and drop-off receipt until the warehouse has accepted the return and the refund appears. New Balance accepts mail returns for online purchases; items bought at a physical New Balance store are returned in store. If the order arrived in multiple boxes, the retailer asks for a separate return label for each box. Do not put unrelated orders or extra merchandise into a package without a return authorization. That can make identification and refund matching harder. A mail return still has to meet the 45-day window and new-condition requirements. If you are near the deadline and a store is accessible, an in-person return may remove uncertainty about transit and the date the warehouse receives the box.
Does New Balance need a separate return label for each box?
For an online order being mailed back in multiple boxes, New Balance asks for a separate label for each box. Use the issued instructions and keep the individual tracking records. Physical-store purchases are returned in store.
Are New Balance returns free?
A qualifying return at a New Balance or New Balance Factory store has no return-shipping charge. For a mailed online return, membership determines the standard label cost: New Balance members get free return shipping, while a nonmember is charged $5 per return, deducted from the refund. That is a per-return cost, so several separately labeled returns can cause several deductions. Check whether you were signed into a membership account for the purchase rather than assuming a later account signup will change the order's original return terms. The return page gives special USPS directions for Alaska, Hawaii, U.S. territories and APO/FPO addresses; use that official route instead of buying postage first. Keep the label email and final refund statement if the deduction looks wrong. New Balance's policy does not describe a general restocking fee for normal qualifying returns.
How much does New Balance deduct for a nonmember’s mailed return?
The standard nonmember return-label charge is $5 per return, deducted from the refund. Members receive free return shipping. Several separately labeled returns can therefore produce several charges; check the membership terms attached to the original order.
Can you return worn New Balance shoes?
The ordinary New Balance policy requires merchandise in new condition. Trying on a pair carefully indoors to check size is different from using it for runs, work or everyday wear, but the retailer inspects the actual product and can reject a used pair under the standard rule. Keep the shoebox, any included accessories and the tags while deciding. Do not assume that a product being uncomfortable after several workouts creates a standard change-of-mind return. A manufacturing-defect or product-warranty question is a separate issue for customer service, with its own evidence and process. There is also a narrower sports-bra Fit Promise for qualifying products; it should not be generalized to all shoes or clothing. Before sending an item by mail, take a clear photo of its condition and retain the drop-off receipt. If its condition is borderline, ask customer service about the exact item rather than paying to mail a return that may be refused.
Does the New Balance Fit Promise allow worn returns?
New Balance's Fit Promise is a specific exception for qualifying sports bras, not a sitewide permission to wear products and send them back. The return page describes a 45-day try-and-wear option for select sports bras purchased after February 1, 2025 at New Balance retail stores or on NewBalance.com. Factory Store purchases are excluded from that offer. Check the bra's eligibility and original purchase channel before using the promise. An online purchase may be handled through the return flow, with the ordinary member or nonmember mail label rules; an eligible store purchase should go to a store. Keep the order email or receipt so support can verify that the product and date fit the offer. For running shoes, socks, apparel and other bras, follow the ordinary new-condition policy unless New Balance explicitly identifies another product-specific guarantee for that item.
Can you exchange New Balance shoes for another size?
New Balance does not offer a direct online exchange through the ordinary web return process. If the size or color is wrong, return the eligible item for a refund and place a new order for the replacement. This can matter during a sale: the replacement is a new purchase at the price and stock available when you order it, and the original refund may arrive later. For a store purchase or an online order brought to a store, ask the associate whether a suitable item is available on that visit; do not rely on a mail exchange being offered. Keep the old order and new order separate so you can track both the payment and refund. If you paid with a promotion or gift card, check the resulting credit before ordering the replacement. The 45-day return deadline still applies to the original item even if the desired size is temporarily unavailable.
Does a New Balance mail return reserve another shoe size?
No. The mail process is a return for refund followed by a separate replacement order. The desired size can sell out or change price while the refund is processed; the original 45-day return deadline still applies.
How long does a New Balance refund take?
For a qualifying in-store return, New Balance says the store processes the refund immediately to the original payment method. A card issuer may need additional posting time before the credit is visible in your account. For mail, the retailer says to allow up to 14 days after the warehouse receives the returned item for the refund to be processed. Shipping time to the warehouse comes first, so the interval from carrier drop-off to a visible card credit can be longer. Track the package, then compare delivery date, return confirmation and payment statement. A $5 nonmember mail fee, if applicable, is deducted from the return amount. If the original payment account is closed, the posted policy describes an eGift Card rather than a credit to an inaccessible account. Contact customer service with the order and tracking numbers if the warehouse received the parcel but the stated processing period has passed.
How do New Balance gift returns work?
A recipient with a New Balance gift should first locate the order email, packing list or gift information that identifies the original transaction. New Balance directs gift returns through Customer Care so it can arrange an eGift Card for an eligible return, while a store can issue a gift card for a qualifying in-store gift return. This is different from refunding the recipient's personal card: the buyer's original payment details may be unavailable or inappropriate to share. The ordinary condition and timing rules still matter, so do not discard packaging and do not wait until a holiday gathering to start checking the purchase date. If an item was bought at another retailer, that seller's gift-return rules govern it. For a gift without documentation, ask New Balance support what evidence they need before visiting or mailing anything. Include the product model and approximate purchase information, but avoid sending sensitive payment data by email or chat.
Can you return New Balance bought from another retailer?
The New Balance return flow covers purchases made directly from NewBalance.com, its stores and qualifying events. A pair bought from a department store, shoe chain, marketplace seller or another brand's outlet must go back to the original seller under that seller's policy. A New Balance logo on the box does not establish that New Balance collected your payment or can refund it. Find the retailer name on your receipt, bank statement or shipping confirmation and use that retailer's return instructions. If the product is defective and the seller's return period has passed, a warranty or product-quality inquiry may be possible, but that is a different process from a routine size return. Do not mail third-party merchandise to the address on New Balance's online return label. The warehouse may be unable to match it to a direct order and the parcel could be delayed or rejected.
How do you contact New Balance about a return?
New Balance lists 800-595-9138 on its official customer-service page and provides chat and other help options there. Its phone hours are published on that page and may change around holidays; check before calling. Have the order number or store receipt, product model, purchase channel, payment method and relevant dates available. For mail, include the return confirmation and carrier tracking number. For an in-store deadline discrepancy, specifically mention both the purchase date and shipment date so support can address the policy wording that applies to your transaction. For a Fit Promise request, give the sports-bra model and purchase date. We did not find a public customer-service email on the cited U.S. help page, so use the official contact options instead of an address circulating on third-party sites. Save the conversation reference if a representative grants a product-specific exception.
Need help with a return?
More clothing & fashion return policies
- Abercrombie & Fitch15 questions answered
- Adidas15 questions answered
- Aerie19 questions answered
- American Eagle15 questions answered
- Ann Taylor18 questions answered
- Anthropologie16 questions answered
Citations
Sources reviewed September 28, 2026. If New Balance updates its rules, its current policy applies. See how we verify.